This site contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.
Fish finders have revolutionized the way anglers locate fish and improve their catch rate when ice fishing. A fish finder uses sonar technology to detect fish, structure, and the bottom of the lake, providing anglers with real-time information that can help them target their prey more efficiently. There are numerous ice fish finders available on the market, making it challenging to choose the best one.
In this guide, we’ll review the top fish finders for ice fishing, highlighting their features, pros, and cons, to help you make an informed decision. Whether you’re an experienced ice angler or a novice looking to improve your catch rate, there’s a fish finder on this list that’s perfect for you.
How are Ice Fishing Fish Finders Different From Standard Models?
An ice fishing fish finder is designed specifically for use on ice and is handheld or mounted on a portable stand. It typically uses a cone-shaped transducer that is placed directly into the hole in the ice. The transducer sends out sound waves through the ice and into the water below and then measures the time it takes for the waves to bounce back. This information is used to create a visual representation of the underwater environment and locate fish.
Additionally, ice fishing fish finders often have a smaller display screen and fewer features than standard fish finders, as they are designed for the specific purpose of ice fishing and do not need to provide as much information as the many factors involved in deep ocean fishing. They also tend to be more portable and easier to use in the freezing and harsh conditions of ice fishing.
My Overall Favorite Ice Fishing Fish Finder
The Striker Plus 4 Fish Finder is great for anyone looking for an economical sonar for ice fishing that can compete with the most expensive models out there. The built-in high-sensitivity GPS and dual-beam ice fishing transducer with Garmin CHIRP traditional sonar provide crystal-clear images and remarkable target separation, making it easier to locate fish and adjust depth.
One of the standout features of the Garmin Striker Plus 4 is its built-in Quickdraw Contours mapping, which allows you to mark and return to selected hot spots. This is particularly useful for ice fishing as it helps reduce the amount of time spent searching for fish, thus increasing the chances of successful catches.
I also appreciate the portable carrying case that comes with this Garmin Fish Finder, which makes it easy to carry and store accessories. The battery life is also impressive, with the ability to last all day on a single charge depending on usage.
In terms of cons, some users may find the 4” color fishfinder screen to be a bit small, and the unit may take some time to learn how to use it effectively. However, these are minor issues and do not detract from the overall performance of the Garmin Striker Plus 4 Fish Finder. Overall, the Garmin STRIKER Plus 4 is an excellent fish finder for its price point and a great addition to any ice fisherman’s gear collection.
Best Value Ice Fishing Fish Finder
There are 4 versions of the Lowrance HOOK2 Fish Finder: the All Season Pack, All Season Pack Plus GPS, GPS Only (No Mapping), and No GPS. This review pertains to the All Season Pack.
First off, the HOOK2 Fish Finder boasts an impressive high-resolution, Solarmax display that comes in five different screen sizes ranging from 4″ to 12″. This is a significant advantage when it comes to ice fishing, as it allows for clear and detailed images of your lake’s underwater environment. Additionally, the autotuning sonar feature ensures that the device is always optimizing its settings for the best possible performance.
One of the standout features of the HOOK2 Fish Finder is its double CHIRP sonar coverage, which provides a more accurate and complete depiction of the underwater environment than many other ice fishing fish finders on the market. In addition, the 2-in-1 and 3-in-1 sonar options, available in certain models, offer expanded widescreen displays that provide a wealth of information on fish location, structure, and bait location, making it easier to find and catch fish under the ice.
Another significant advantage of the HOOK2 is its built-in enhanced base map from C-MAP, which offers detailed mapping of underwater structures and topography. Upgraded mapping options from C-MAP and Navionics are also available to further expand the capabilities of the device.
While the HOOK2 Fish Finder has a lot to offer, there are some downsides to consider. One potential drawback is that the GPS-only version does not include mapping capabilities, which may be a dealbreaker for some ice-fishing enthusiasts. I would recommend staying away from this version. Additionally, the cost of the device may be a bit steep for those who are just starting with ice fishing, as some variations of the HOOK2 Fish Finder can be somewhat expensive. Fortunately, it’s nowhere near the highest-priced fish finders available. Thus, I believe that the Lowrance HOOK2 Fish Finder is a great investment for those who are serious about the sport.
Best Old School Ice Fishing Flasher
The Humminbird ICE-35 Fish Finder is an excellent choice for any ice angler who prefers a traditional flasher. The dual beam sonar allows for precise targeting of fish, structure, and lures, with the option to choose between a narrow or wide beam. The 3-color fiber-optic flasher display is highly visible and accurately indicates the bottom, fish, and lure in real-time, making it easy to spot fish and adjust your presentation accordingly.
One of the standout features of the Humminbird ICE-35 is the 2X dynamic zoom, which allows you to magnify your view of a specific depth range and rotate the dial to change the area you’re zooming into. This is helpful when you’re trying to pinpoint fish in a specific depth range.
The adjustable gain is also a great feature, as it allows you to dial in the sensitivity of your flasher unit to match your fishing scenario, providing greater accuracy and precision. The Humminbird ICE-35 also offers adjustable depth ranges, ranging from 1X to 10X, allowing you to fish depths up to 200 feet. This provides greater versatility and flexibility, allowing you to adjust your fishing strategy to suit the conditions.
The battery life is impressive, and you can use it for multiple days without needing to charge it. The unit is also easy to set up and use, with a screen that is easily visible in all conditions.
One minor drawback of the Humminbird ICE-35 is that I find it a bit pricey for an ice fishing flasher; however, the features and benefits it provides are worth the investment in my opinion.
Most Advanced Ice Fishing Fish Finder
Looking for a high-tech ice fishing fish finder? The Garmin Striker Plus 5 Fish Finder is an exceptional piece of equipment that serious ice anglers should consider adding to their arsenal. It’s expensive, but it’s intended for veteran ice fishers who seek the best.
Even with all of its advanced features, the Striker Plus 5 is fairly easy to use. The bright, sunlight-readable 5″ display provides a clear view of everything below the ice. The built-in GPS is a game-changer, allowing you to mark and return to your favorite fishing spots with ease. Similar to the Striker Plus 4, the Plus 5 model includes a CHIRP ice fishing transducer that provides crisp, clear fish arches and excellent target separation.
The built-in Garmin Quickdraw Contours mapping software is another major highlight of the Striker Plus 5. With this feature, you can create and store maps with 1′ contours for up to 2 million acres, making it easy to identify changes in depth and bottom structure. This feature has saved ice fishing pros countless hours of scouting and mapping new fishing areas.
One feature that sets the Garmin Striker Plus 5 apart from other fish finders (apart from the ICE-35) is the built-in flasher. This feature lets you see your jig or weighted bait and the depth of fish as they swim into the sonar beam. This makes it incredibly easy to adjust your presentation and target specific fish.
The main downside of the Garmin Striker Plus 5 is the premium price. It is quite expensive compared to other ice fishing sonar units on the market. However, if you are serious about ice fishing and want the best possible equipment, then I would say that the Garmin Striker Plus 5 is worth it!
Increase Your Catch Rate with a Top Ice Fishing Fish Finder
An ice fishing fish finder is an essential tool for any ice angler looking to improve their catch rate. The four fish finders reviewed in this article offer a range of features and capabilities to suit different needs and budgets. Whether you’re looking for an economical option that gets the job done, or a top tier device with high-tech capabilities, there’s an ice fish finder out there that can help you locate fish under the ice and improve your chances of reeling in dinner.
